Goodbye job applications, hello dream career
Seize control of your career and design the future you deserve with LW career

‘Urgent’ legal action needed to review COVID-19 in nursing homes

The devastating deaths of residents at the Newmarch House nursing home have prompted calls for an inquiry into the handling of all cases of COVID-19 in elderly patients.

user iconNaomi Neilson 08 May 2020 SME Law
nursing homes
expand image

The outbreak of the coronavirus in the Newmarch House nursing home has since resulted in 60 cases and 16 deaths, at the time of writing. It began after an infected nurse worked six shifts last month, despite displaying mild symptoms of COVID-19.

Infected residents appear to go days without treatment from doctors and nurses and there has been a “failure” to limit the number of cases or move residents to hospital.

The Australian Lawyers Alliance (ALA) has called for a “purposeful” inquiry into the house that works separately to the aged care royal commission, so that it will not “get lost”.

“The residents of Newmarch House and their families have legal rights and, as community we need to understand what went wrong in the management of the outbreak,” said ALA’s spokesperson, lawyer and aged care advocate Catherine Henry.

Ms Henry said holding an inquiry into the “disaster” will provide the opportunity for review of the situation and draw the federal government’s attention to the underlying issues.

“It seems that what we are seeing [unfolding] at Newmarch House is a failure to meet accepted standards with undertrained, inexperienced staff being forced to handle the outbreak and the facility neglecting to provide adequate resources for its residents,” Ms Henry said.

Premier Gladys Berejiklian conceded that “horrible mistakes were made” and the nursing home is an example of where things need to happen better.

Another cluster of the virus was found in nursing homes in Melbourne’s west. Slater and Gordon principal lawyer Neil Andrews said those who have been diagnosed may be able to claim an impairment lump sum if negligence from employers is found.

“A worker has a right to claim weekly payments for time off work, medical and any similar expenses if they contract an illness at work, whether there is fault by the employer or not. COVID hotspots could emerge in a range of different workplaces over the next months. Health and aged care workers will be particularly at risk,” Mr Andrews said.

“Employers need to adhere to their obligations to maintain a safe workplace. Employees should speak up and/or seek advice if they feel their safety is at risk.”

Naomi Neilson

Naomi Neilson

Naomi Neilson is a senior journalist with a focus on court reporting for Lawyers Weekly. 

You can email Naomi at: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

You need to be a member to post comments. Become a member for free today!