You have0 free article left this month.
Register for a free account to access unlimited free content.
You have 0 free article left this month.
Register for a free account to access unlimited free content.

Lawyers Weekly - legal news for Australian lawyers

Powered by MOMENTUM MEDIA
lawyers weekly logo

Powered by MOMENTUM MEDIA

Goodbye job applications, hello dream career
Seize control of your career and design the future you deserve with LW career

Daniel Andrews hit with another class action

The Andrews government has been hit with another class action on behalf of workers who lost their jobs following the state’s most recent round of lockdowns.

user iconTony Zhang 18 September 2020 Big Law
Daniel Andrews hit with another class action
expand image

Tony Carbone, managing partner from Carbone Lawyers is representing over a hundred plaintiffs who were made redundant following Victoria’s descent into stage three and four restrictions in late July, including hairdressers, gardeners, real estate agents and more.

Mr Carbone said that the civil suit argues that the Victorian government is liable for damages for its failed hotel quarantine program, which is believed to have led to the state’s second COVID-19 outbreak and the toughest restrictions in the country’s history.

“We’re saying that anyone who has lost their job or lost income because of the second lockdown is part of our case. It’s a big group,” Mr Carbone said.

“All the people I am representing for income loss are beside themselves. When we decided to launch this class action, it was out of that desperation for the people that don’t know which way they’re turning anymore.”

Mr Carbone found that the second lockdown has wiped out many businesses and devastated numerous employers and employees alike.

“Most employers that I spoke to prior to the second round of lockdowns were very optimistic about getting back to 60 per cent, 70 per cent or 80 per cent of capacity by the end of the year, he said.

I’ve spoken to a lot of these people in recent times and they’ve been very, very disheartened.

“I’ve heard from real estate agents, gardeners and hairdressers that have gone through the last two to three months without any income.”

Mr Carbone finds justification for the case in findings released by Dr Charles Alpren, an epidemiologist with the Victorian Department of Health and Human Services, that point to a link between hotel quarantine and 99 per cent of Victoria’s COVID cases.

If not for the state government’s inept handling of the hotel quarantine, we wouldnt have had the second round of lockdowns and people wouldnt have lost their jobs, he said.

The lead plaintiff in the class action against the government is 21-year-old Jordan Roberts, who was made redundant because of the pandemic less than a fortnight after stage four restrictions were imposed on metropolitan Melbourne.

Mr Carbone said Mr Roberts suffered a “psychological reaction marked by depression and anxiety” and “nervous shock” because of the restrictions with subsequent medical expenses.

I understand my boss is also struggling and he’s also finding it difficult to make ends meet. I’ve been looking for other work but there’s just nothing out there, Mr Roberts said.

Mr Roberts said he remained hopeful his former employer would rehire him if the economy rebounds.

Victoria now faces three major lawsuits, after a Mornington Peninsula cafe owner sued the state over its curfew restrictions along with another multibillion-dollar class action suit launched by Quinn Emanuel from businesses affected by the stage four COVID-19 lockdown.

Comments (10)
  • Avatar
    He also should be charged on criminal offenses he should immediately resign
    Anon wrote:
    Ridiculous! Leave the nan alone, he has done his best based on expert advice. Probably saved thousands of lives, and did the rest if Australia adavour bycontaining it. He should receive a medal.
    0
  • Avatar
    Your comment is what is "ridiculous". Every other state in Australia contained the virus, by acting with competence.
    0
  • Avatar
    I've gained five kilos during lockdown due to a lack of exercise. I'm sure I am not the only one, so let's start a class action against the Premier!
    1
  • Avatar
    Whilst the class actions would seem to be warranted, it is well to appreciate that the fruits of successful actions against Premier Andrews and other Ministers, as well as their defence costs, will almost certainly come from the Victorian public purse. So much for his "I'm responsible" acknowledgement! Responsibility in politics, and responsibility in the real world, surely are two very different things.
    0
  • Avatar
    Ridiculous! Leave the nan alone, he has done his best based on expert advice. Probably saved thousands of lives, and did the rest if Australia adavour bycontaining it. He should receive a medal.
    1
    • Avatar
      Look around the rest of Australia and how each of the other States and Territories enforced hotel quarantine. Now look at the only State to have had a second wave which emanated from the hotel quarantine process. That alone raises real questions of competence by the Victorian government. Throw in the use of amateur security guards with no authority to manage the process and it presents at least a prima facie case.
      0
    • Avatar
      The only thing Premier Andrews should be given, is the boot! ?
      1
    • Avatar
      Based on expert advice, so who was the expert that suggested the curfew? It wasn’t the Chief Health Officer nor was it the Police Commissioner like Andrews has claimed. So I’m curious which expert?
      2
    • Avatar
      This is inevitable and the plaintiffs should have recourse. I don’t recall anyone ever polling the vulnerable elderly bracket to see if they want our country to commit economic suicide just to save them. Many would say “I’ll take my chances”, but then they were not consulted. Taiwan is a great example of community engagement on Covid action and taking steps to protect the vulnerable has enabled them to keep the floodgates wide open with a low death rate and without condemning everyone else to ruin. Everyone who refers to saving lives at all costs forgets that economic ruin leads to rapid rise in the death rate. Let’s not get too sanctimonious and start working out how we can manage things without ruining what makes us great.
      0
  • Avatar
    Time to hold these tinpot dictators to account.
    2
Avatar
Attach images by dragging & dropping or by selecting them.
The maximum file size for uploads is MB. Only files are allowed.
 
The maximum number of 3 allowed files to upload has been reached. If you want to upload more files you have to delete one of the existing uploaded files first.
The maximum number of 3 allowed files to upload has been reached. If you want to upload more files you have to delete one of the existing uploaded files first.
Posting as
You need to be a member to post comments. Become a member for free today!