You have 2 free articles left this month.
Become a Premium Member to enjoy a wide range of benefits.
You have 2 free articles left this month.

Lawyers Weekly - legal news for Australian lawyers

Powered by MOMENTUM MEDIA
lawyers weekly logo
SME Law

Je suis Clifford Chance

Clifford Chance rookie Aysh Chaudhry (pictured), 22, has received international notoriety after ranting about the Charlie Hebdo massacre in a YouTube video.

January 20, 2015 By Felicity Nelson
Aysh Chaudhry
expand image

The overwhelming response of the Western world has been to stand by the fallen Parisian satirists and uphold their right to free speech, but Chaudhry argues they had it coming.

“Brothers and sisters, we would not be here had it not been for the fact that the kuffar had gone to our lands and killed our people and raped and pillaged our resources,” he said in the 21-minute video, which was watched 700 times before being removed.

‘Kuffar’ is a derogatory term for non-Muslims, often equated with ‘infidel’.

Chaudhry said that Muslims should not be apologetic about ‘Islamic responses’ to “attacks on Islam” and should cast off the “Western cultural lens” through which they view insults to their religion.

It is unclear what Chaudhry means by an ‘Islamic response’ but he does not say he condones the execution of cartoonists and innocent bystanders in his video.

“We are becoming infatuated with the civilisation of the kuffar and their beliefs and their values and indeed we have latched on to these,” he said.

Chaudhry ranted that freedom of speech was not a reality, but successfully undermined his own point by using Holocaust deniers as his only example.  

“You wouldn't walk around Germany denying the Holocaust,” he said.

He equated freedom of speech with “absolute freedom to insult Muslims”.

“Stop putting freedom on this pedestal. This is a value stemming from secular, liberal beliefs. We don't need a value which stems from a bankrupt ideology,” he said.

As a lover of all things ironic, Folklaw couldn’t listen to this incoherent outburst against free speech without supressing a grin – how amusing to be vocally attacking the very activity one is engaging in!

These are dark days in France. The Paris attacks left 17 dead, including Charlie Hebdo cartoonists, a policewoman, the gunmen and the four hostages they killed at a kosher supermarket.

Chaudhry was quick to apologise for his tasteless comments, saying he “had no intention other than to encourage intellectual debate and would never support or condone violence”.

Clifford Chance has not said what disciplinary action it will take in response to Chaudhry’s video.

The trainee lawyer only started at Clifford Chance in London six months ago, after completing internship programs at other high-profile law firms, including Slaughter & May, White & Case, Freshfields and Berwin Leighton Paisner.

A spokesperson for Clifford Chance told the press: “The views expressed in this video are personal and not those of Clifford Chance. The firm is committed to establishing an inclusive culture where people with diverse backgrounds and views work effectively together and feel confident to develop their potential.

“We ask our people to at all times consider how their personal conduct and actions may affect those around them, their professional reputation and that of the firm.”

Comments (10)
  • Avatar
    <p>Do you have personal knowledge of his excellence as a graduate? How insightful of you to be able to make such a compelling statement about an individual who has in one 21minute video denounced the entirety of the west and the respect to freedom of speech alongside belittling the memory of the people murdered in the name of religion. An individual who has obtained his entire education, his degree, experience and his significant paycheck on the backs of the "kuffars" that he so condemns. A modicum of respect might exist towards this excuse of a human being if he was not such an extraordinary hypocrite. People like this are abhorrent cancers on the free society millions have worked to ensure in the UK and to allow his conduct with no repercussion is to diminish the sacrifice of the Parisian victims and the thousands of innocents that have been slaughtered over the decades in the name of Islam </p>
    0
  • Avatar
    <p>As the article says, 'kuffar' is a derogatory term for non-Muslims. Derogatory expressions targeting particular ethnic or religious groups are by their nature racist or in some way discriminatory. I certainly wouldn't tolerate a white person using the N word towards an African-American or an Aborigine. Whoever utters such expressions, be they white, black, brown, yellow or pink with green spots, they should be condemned across the board.</p><p>And so what if this idiot is an "excellent graduate"? Just what does that prove? A surprising number of prominent Nazis were graduates too. Regrettably, an education may do little to make someone better as a person.</p>
    0
  • Avatar
    <p>How was the rant racist? Clifford chance are keeping him on. He is an excellent graduate</p>
    0
  • Avatar
    <p>D'oh, since when does tasteless racist ranting amount to starting an 'intellectual debate'? Get rid of this guy now, Clifford Chance, before you are tarred with his brush or, at best, left with egg on your face. Je suis disgusted.</p>
    0
  • Avatar
    <p>No contract for him me thinks!!</p>
    0
  • Avatar
    <p>I think we can expect that his career working for Kuffars will come to an end.</p><p>It is one thing to suspect your employee thinks little of you and your firm's clients, it is another to know that he shouted it out to the world. </p>
    0
  • Avatar
    <p>Not completely comfortable with the fusion of comedy and editorial in the article - perhaps better to have one or the other?</p>
    0
  • Avatar
    <p>Regardless of the debate on freedom of speech, it is highly likely most law firms would consider his actions as bringing the firm into disrepute. In which case, that'll be goodbye law career Mr Chaudhry!</p>
    0
  • Avatar
    <p>"Kuffar " is a highly derogatory word used against non believers by Islamic supremacists such as ISIS. It's English language equivalents are n****r or p**i. He has not apologised for the use of this word, nor will he as to do so would be to give up his belief that there is only one true religion and it should dominate the world and in that new world all kuffars will be second class citizens. </p>
    0
  • Avatar
    <p>This article is a little simplistic.</p><p>No one would deny that the trainee lawyer in question has the right to say what he said. That is after all the essence of freedom of speech enshrined directly in UK law by the HRA 1998.</p><p>The mistake that you make however Felicy, is that you assume that this right ends the debate. Just because you have the freedom to express a view doesn't mean you should do so: especially when you post said rant for all the world to see on youtube. While he has the freedom to say what he likes, only a child believes that you can express any view without consequence.</p><p>While his views are shocking - he condemns Muslims who expressed regret over the attack and uses the racial epithet "kuffar" - that is not really the salient issue.</p><p>The issue is the quality of his professional judgement in posting the video in the first place. Lawyers are expected to uphold very stringent professional ethics and have a contractual duty, usually expressed very clearly in their employment contract, not to bring "their firm into disrepute." Unfortunately, this episode does just that to Clifford Chance. This article could have addressed some of these issues.</p>
    0
Avatar
Attach images by dragging & dropping or by selecting them.
The maximum file size for uploads is MB. Only files are allowed.
 
The maximum number of 3 allowed files to upload has been reached. If you want to upload more files you have to delete one of the existing uploaded files first.
The maximum number of 3 allowed files to upload has been reached. If you want to upload more files you have to delete one of the existing uploaded files first.
Posting as
You need to be a member to post comments. Become a member today
Got a tip for us?
If you have any news tips or stories to share, feel free to send them our way.
Momentum Media Logo
Most Innovative Company