You have4 free articles left this month.
Register for a free account to access unlimited free content.
You have 4 free articles left this month.
Register for a free account to access unlimited free content.

Lawyers Weekly - legal news for Australian lawyers

Powered by MOMENTUM MEDIA
lawyers weekly logo

Powered by MOMENTUM MEDIA

Goodbye job applications, hello dream career
Seize control of your career and design the future you deserve with LW career

Dealing with depression

Depression is nearly always in the news. It is perhaps the most pervasive ailment that afflicts lawyers, who are the most depressed of all the professions. A disproportionate number of lawyers commit suicide, usually in middle age, writes Bob Murray.

user iconBob Murray 05 January 2017 Corporate Counsel
Bob Murray
expand image

I don’t want to go into what everyone else has gone over. Rather, I want to look at the affliction from a different angle and use the latest findings from biological psychiatry, behavioural neurogenetics, psychology (my fields) and evolutionary studies to throw some light on the affliction, and to suggest some simple remedies to alleviate it in firms.

First, to clear away some misconceptions. To begin with, we have no idea of the complete range of causes for depression.

We know that it is closely linked to stress, particularly workplace stress and anxiety. We know that it is about 40 per cent genetic (it tends to run in families). We have learned recently that it’s not really one illness but a syndrome – multiple illnesses with similar symptoms  and that no one cure works for all depressive states. We also now know that that childhood abuse and neglect are closely associated with depression, as is early pressure to succeed at school or in sport.

We have become aware that depression is closely tied in with the way work and society are organised and that pollution, lack of exercise, living or working in a high-rise building, having little contact with nature and any significant failed or lost relationship can all be contributory factors. We are realising that men and women have different symptoms and that although we used to think that the rate of depression for women was twice that of men, we now know that that is false and the real rates are pretty similar.

Depression is usually classed as either mild (dysthymia), moderate or severe. All can be reactive to a particular event (e.g. childbirth or pregnancy, or the loss of a spouse, a job or even a major client) episodic (it comes and goes with greater or lesser intensity) or chronic (which is when the episodes tend to run into one another).

Within severe depression there are two important sub-groups: major depressive disorder (MDD) and treatment-resistant depression (TRD).

For moderate-to-severe depression, MDD and TRD there is no definite cure. Since the University of Hull study in 2008 we have known that no pharmaceutical approach works any better than a placebo for any depression in the long term. Talk therapy doesn’t work at all for MDD or TRD.

Several promising approaches are being tested and, in the US at least, applied in practice: for example, the use of ketamine and transcranial stimulation (TS). There is no evidence that any of them work in the long term, although ketamine is known to have immediate beneficial effects in short-term treatment of MDD and TRD.

TS treatment may have a somewhat longer shelf life but it takes longer to work. Many US hospitals are now using ketamine in crisis intervention with suicidal patients. Britain, for reasons to do with its use as a street drug, has banned the use of ketamine altogether. Crazy, as lives will be lost as a result.

Also promising are the new ways scientists are looking at a number of neurochemicals, especially glutamate and dopamine, and how they signal within the brain. Both are also key parts of the brain’s reward system (oxytocin being the other major component).

The lack of either can lead to serious complications, including mood disorders and addiction. In fact, studies have shown that depression and addiction in lawyers are very closely linked and often the addiction to alcohol or drugs is an attempt to disguise or to overcome the illness.

Lawyers are twice as likely to suffer from alcoholism and other addictions than the rest of the population.

The disruption of the reward system leads to anhedonia (the inability to find pleasure in activities) and problems with memory and learning, which are major symptoms of all kinds of depression. This has led to attempts to use drugs to control the amount of both glutamate and dopamine. So far without a great deal of success, although simple praise and recognition have been shown to increase the flow of dopamine and enhance mood and learning, at least in the short term.

One of the main problems for law firms right now is the chronic need to innovate and try new ways of doing things. Yet lawyers are notoriously reluctant to learn new things and to change. I believe the research shows that this reluctance is tied to depression. One of the key symptoms of depression, especially MDD and TRD, is the inability of the brain to try new behaviours.

The business of law and the careers of lawyers in the high-tech 'new normal' is therefore, I believe, being held back by the prevalence of depression. Accountants are not nearly so depressed, which might explain why the big four have left most law firms in the dust.

We will find cures, not one magic bullet, because depression, as I said, is a syndrome. But in the mean time there are things that law firms can do to alleviate the problem:

1. Reduce the level of stress within the firm

This is much simpler and less expensive than most people think and, if done systemically, can enormously increase profits and performance.

2. Make sure that the organisation has a culture of praise rather than blame

In most firms it’s the opposite. A culture of praise, as the famous Gallup study discovered, can increase output and profits by up to 20 per cent.

3. Clamp down on egregious partner behaviour, especially bullying

Do not let people get away with bad behaviour simply because they bring in a lot of money. Even witnessing other people suffering from bad behaviour can lower the working of both the reward system and the immune system, and therefore the overall profitability and flexibility of the firm.

Dr Bob Murray is the principal at consultancy Fortinberry Murray and co-author (with Dr Alicia Fortinberry) of Leading the Future: The Human Science of Law Firm Strategy and Leadership.

Comments (3)
  • Avatar
    Thanks Bob for your article and Michael for your comments. Noting Michael's "The only thing worse than your egregious partner behaviour and bullying is the timid response of other partners" and Bob's "we get so confused by the complicated pronouncements of "experts"" is it simply about leadership...and then we take it form there?
    0
  • Avatar
    This is a very good article, with more depth than I usually read in bulletins and with more up-front comments about the reality.
    We all have our own experience and perceptions but I am surprised to see that “no pharmaceutical approach works any better than a placebo for any depression in the long term”, my experience and observations being otherwise, in some cases.
    I don’t have any agenda between law and accounting firms and maybe the big four – never sure who they are – are well ahead. But I think that law firms are ahead on gender and diversity issues, though well behind the public sector.
    It is an interesting idea that law firms are ‘depressed’ and hence languish! Would we put the courts in there as well? A depressed judge could be a real problem.
    As to resistance to change, I find many lawyers frustrated by the need for change but law reform or change does not happen. How long do we have to wait for electronic land transfers, remote court attendance, and open access to corporate data?
    Perhaps lawyers are more constrained by external factors - parliament – than accountants.
    I don’t disagree with your remedies, motherhood as they may appear. The first has to come from the top, but those at the top are not the sort that would appreciate the need for this.
    A culture of praise is important, and praise also for those who do things outside the law – a young lawyer’s academic or athletic achievement.
    The only thing worse than your egregious partner behaviour and bullying is the timid response of other partners, often motivated by monetary self-interest, or hierarchy. Again, these sort of people are attracted to the law. Hard to break the cycle.
    Also, those with MDD or TRD may well be disguising, and managing, their depression by intellectual efforts in their work, itself something that can lift a mood, rather than drugs or alcohol, or a 'rest'. The difficulty for them is that work becomes too consuming.
    I don’t know if your research covers the public legal sector, where much of what you describe at 3 is contained and restrained; and the culture of money is much less; with many working for the public interest, and clients.
    You will not agree with my final point, that those with MDD or TRD should not be working in law firms. It would be a reason I would certainly take into account in considering an applicant for a job. The very symptoms of severe or on-going depression are inherently detrimental to what is required of a lawyer, indeed most jobs.
    Perhaps I should read you book? which may usefully change my mere anecdotal views.

    0
    • Avatar
      I agree with your comments, and thanks for the praise of the piece. Yes, the remedies are "motherhood" and on the face of it obvious. However often we get so confused by the complicated pronouncements of "experts" (who may or may not actually have the expertise) that we overlook the obvious.
      One further fact that comes out of your comment. Several recent studies have shown that due to increased workplace stress (in 5 years it will have increased by over 200% since 2013) the rate of depression (including dysthymia, moderate depression MDD and TRD, in the workplace in general is about 30%).
      And, yes, you should read the book!
      0
Avatar
Attach images by dragging & dropping or by selecting them.
The maximum file size for uploads is MB. Only files are allowed.
 
The maximum number of 3 allowed files to upload has been reached. If you want to upload more files you have to delete one of the existing uploaded files first.
The maximum number of 3 allowed files to upload has been reached. If you want to upload more files you have to delete one of the existing uploaded files first.
Posting as
You need to be a member to post comments. Become a member for free today!