Login
Jagot swearing-in breaks a glass ceiling
Justice Jayne Jagot’s swearing-in will bring about the first female majority of the High Court in Australia and represents a major step forward in Australia’s justice system, one Australian National University law academic says.
Jess Feyder
Dr Heather Roberts, from the ANU College of Law, is an expert on judicial swearing-in ceremonies and said that Justice Jagot’s appointment to the High Court is a “historic moment” for Australia’s legal profession and significant worldwide.
“When Justice Gaudron was sworn in, she was the only female voice and the only female officially recorded as being present,” Dr Roberts noted.
“On Monday [17 October], there will be four female High Court judges — Chief Justice Kiefel, Justice Michelle Gordon, Justice Jacqueline Gleeson and Justice Jayne Jagot — and many senior female members of the legal profession,” she commented.
Dr Roberts said Justice Jagot’s appointment is an important recognition of the value of diversity in the judiciary.
“Justice Jagot is universally recognised as a brilliant legal mind and brings her lived experience as a child of migrants and attending public schools,” Dr Roberts explained.
“She is an example that the search for leadership and talent should not be confined to a narrow, privileged elite.
“It is vitally important to the legitimacy of the courts that they should reflect the broad experiences of the Australian community.”
Dr Roberts explained that the swearing-in ceremony dates back to 1903 when Sir Samuel Griffith took the oath as the nation’s first chief justice.
The speeches often give new insight into the background and vision of the new justice and the Attorney-General’s priorities and approach to judicial appointments.
“The ceremony provides a rare glimpse of judges as people — with families and hobbies — and to hear how their professional careers developed,” Dr Roberts said.
In previous ceremonies for female judges, welcome speeches from the legal profession often placed great emphasis on the judge as a wife or mother, or their clothing choices, Dr Roberts explained.
“More recent ceremonies have recognised the discrimination that women lawyers faced in breaking the glass ceilings of the profession, and the importance of women judges as role models for both male and female lawyers, and of a diverse judiciary,” she noted.
“While Australia will become one of a few countries worldwide with a female majority on its apex court, this does not mean that Australia should become complacent in working toward the goal of judicial diversity.
“Apex courts internationally have begun to reflect the cultural diversity of their communities. But much work remains to be done in Australia to ensure that cultural and ethnic diversity is better reflected in the courts.”
